Sunday, October 19, 2025

A Review of The Lady with the Little Dog and Other Stories 1896-1904, by Anton Chekhov

I. Most great literature is about specific human beings in specific human environments, and much of their content is about the peculiarities of those humans, the things that they do, their social relations, and how what they do relates to what other people are doing. In other words, they are stitched together from elements cut out of the rich and sophisticated lifeworld of culture, society, morality, and politics and coloured by social emotions like gratitude, resentment, shame, guilt, pride, ambition, greed, envy, fellowship, and love which constitute the everyday character of that world. They are about what we might call human situations. These situations are the typical (but by no means only) subject of great literature.

These situations obviously do not come from nothing; the author must describe them through the act of writing. But nor do these descriptions come from nowhere, for the description itself must come from some or other perspective. For example, a novel may be written from a sort of view from nowhere, from an inhuman, omniscient third person that does not think or feel in the ways we do, but instead merely observes and describes, doing so through bare, indiscriminate statements of fact and reports of things said, in a way that does not privilege the specific perspectives of any specific characters. Or it may be written about from the first person, exclusively from the perspective of just one character. Or it may be somewhere in between these possibilities, where the writing takes the perspective, largely, of one or several characters, but intentionally leaves the perspective of others’ opaque, thereby blending and keeping distinct various perspectives.